Gear guide

Best cross stitch frames: Q-Snap frames and scroll frames compared

Updated Picked from Amazon listings, not hands-on tests. How we pick

Detailed view of embroidery work on yellow fabric with intricate patterns
Photo: Muhammad Khawar Nazir on Pexels

A hoop works until the design is bigger than the hoop. For a large cross stitch piece there are two kinds of frame. A Q-Snap frame is a square of PVC tubing: the fabric is laid over it and held by clamps that snap onto each side, so nothing is sewn on. Q-Snap sizes are 6x6, 8x8, 11x11, 11x17 and 17x17 in, measured outside, so the stitching area is a little smaller than the name. A scroll frame (also called a roll frame) is two wooden roller bars joined by side bars: the spare fabric is rolled up and only the strip being worked is exposed, which suits long designs. To match a frame to a project, divide the stitch count by the fabric count: a 100 x 100 stitch design on 14 count aida is 7.1 in across, so it sits inside an 11x11 frame, while on a smaller frame the fabric is moved as you go. This guide compares both types by size, material, how the fabric is held and stated stand compatibility, using only what each listing says. Nothing was tested.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change our picks. Affiliate disclosure
New to Prime? Try Prime free for fast, free shipping on eligible items.

Top picks at a glance

Compare all picks
  • Closest match for the job

    Q-Snap Needlework Frame Bundle, 3 Sizes

    The bundle lists one 11x11 frame, one 8x8 frame, one 6x6 frame and one extension kit, each with its Q-Snap part number.

    See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon
  • Most for the money on paper

    ziqianhard beech scroll frame, 18.1 x 11.2 in

    The listing gives both figures: frame size 18.1 x 11.2 in and working area about 16.5 x 9 in.

    See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon
  • Most complete listing

    Q-Snap Frame Set, 11 x 11 in with 14 x 14 Kit

    The set includes an 11 x 11 in Q-Snap frame plus an extension kit to convert the frame to 14 x 14 inches.

    See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon

Compare the picks

The picks in detail

Pick 1 · CYB

Q-Snap Needlework Frame Bundle, 3 Sizes

See price on Amazon

Three Q-Snap frames in one bundle, 11x11, 8x8 and 6x6 in, with an extension kit. It covers small to large projects for someone setting up with snap frames from scratch.

What the listing offers

  • The bundle lists one 11x11 frame, one 8x8 frame, one 6x6 frame and one extension kit, each with its Q-Snap part number.
  • The listing says fabric tension adjusts without removing the fabric from the frame.
  • Frames are PVC tubing, and the spec sheet names embroidery, cross stitch, quilting and beading among the uses.

Limits to know

  • The manufacturer does not say what frame sizes the extension kit makes when combined with the three frames.
  • The brand field shows CYB, the bundle seller, not Q-Snap: the frames are identified only by their Q-Snap part numbers.
See it on AmazonListing title: Q-Snap Needlework Frame Bundle: 11x11, 8x8, 6x6, and Extension Kit

Pick 2 · ThingamaJungle

Q-Snap Frame Set, 11 x 11 in with 14 x 14 Kit

See price on Amazon

An 11 x 11 in Q-Snap frame bundled with an extension kit that converts it to 14 x 14 in. One set gives two frame sizes, for stitchers whose projects vary between medium and large.

What the listing offers

  • The set includes an 11 x 11 in Q-Snap frame plus an extension kit to convert the frame to 14 x 14 inches.
  • Described in the listing as lightweight PVC with clamps that hold the fabric taut.
  • The manufacturer names quilting, cross stitch, embroidery and other types of needlework as uses.

Limits to know

  • Sold as a set by ThingamaJungle rather than by Q-Snap, with a decorative vinyl sticker that adds nothing to the frame.
  • The product page does not say how many clamps come with the extension kit or give the working area at either size.
See it on AmazonListing title: Q-Snap Set: 11 x 11 inch Frame, 14 x 14 inch Extension Kit & Decorativ...

Pick 3 · AllAboutEmbroideryUA

Beech Needlepoint Scroll Frame, 15.7 x 22 in

See price on Amazon

A beech wood scroll frame titled 15.7 x 22 in, with plastic clips that grip the fabric along the bars. For large pieces that are rolled as the work progresses, and the one pick here with a stated stand fit.

What the listing offers

  • Made of beech wood that the listing describes as well polished and smooth.
  • Flexible plastic clips attach the fabric to the bar all the way across, and the work can be rolled when needed.
  • The spec sheet states the frame fits all AllAboutEmbroideryUA stands and comes with instructions and a QR code for a video tutorial.

Limits to know

  • The title gives one size, 15.7 x 22 in, without saying whether that is the outside measurement or the working area.
  • Stand compatibility is stated only for the maker's own stands, not for other brands.
See it on AmazonListing title: Needlepoint Embroidery Tapestry Scroll Frame Made of Organic Beech, Wo...

Pick 4 · ziqianhard

ziqianhard beech scroll frame, 18.1 x 11.2 in

See price on Amazon

A beech scroll frame measuring 18.1 x 11.2 in overall, with a working area of about 16.5 x 9 in. A mid-size roll frame for wide or long designs that are rolled as they grow.

What the listing offers

  • The listing gives both figures: frame size 18.1 x 11.2 in and working area about 16.5 x 9 in.
  • Made of beech wood, described on the product page as polished smooth with no roughness.
  • Plastic clips hold the fabric to the bar all the way across, and the work can be rolled when needed.

Limits to know

  • No floor stand or lap stand compatibility is mentioned in the spec sheet.
  • The brand is little known, and the listing text closely repeats that of other beech scroll frames.
See it on AmazonListing title: Beech Wood Tapestry Scroll Embroidery Frames, Needlepoint Cross Stitch...

Pick 5 · Yookeer

Yookeer wooden scroll frame, 12 x 21 in

See price on Amazon

A wooden scroll frame about 12 x 21 in overall after assembly, with a working area of about 10 x 18 in. According to the listing, the fabric is tightened by rotating the roller.

What the listing offers

  • Overall size after assembly is given as about 30.5 x 54.5 cm (12 x 21 in), with a working area of about 25.5 x 46 cm.
  • The spec sheet says the tightness of the embroidery cloth is adjusted by rotating the column.
  • It comes apart when not in use to save storage space, and the pack is stated as one frame.

Limits to know

  • The wood species is not named: the manufacturer says only that the frame is wood.
  • The visible listing text does not explain how the fabric attaches to the rollers, and no stand compatibility is given.
See it on AmazonListing title: Needlepoint Embroidery Tapestry Scroll Frame Cross Stitch Frame Wooden

Read before you buy

More gear for the hoop and frame stage

Hoop and Floss chooses every product independently from what its Amazon listing states. We may earn a commission from the links above. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.