Comparison
Embroidery needle vs sewing needle: what is the difference?
Published
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change our picks. Affiliate disclosure
New to Prime? Try Prime free for fast, free shipping on eligible items.
Short answer
An embroidery (crewel) needle and a regular sewing needle (a sharp) of the same size have the same sharp point and about the same diameter and length. The difference is the eye: long and oval on the embroidery needle, small and round on the sharp. A sharp works for 1 or 2 strands of floss. Three or more strands need the longer eye.
Gear for this job
All 6 picks comparedClover Gold Eye Embroidery Needles, 16 Pack
See price on AmazonSee it on AmazonJohn James embroidery needles, sizes 5/10, 16 pcs
See price on AmazonSee it on AmazonSINGER Crewel Needles in Dial Compact, Set of 24
See price on AmazonSee it on Amazon
This page is for anyone who has a packet of ordinary sewing needles and wonders if a separate pack of embroidery needles is worth buying. Both are hand needles, both are numbered 1 to 12, and in both a bigger number is a finer needle. What decides the answer is how many strands of embroidery floss you plan to thread at once. 'Regular needle' here means a sharp, the general purpose hand sewing needle. Sewing machine needles and machine embroidery needles are a separate topic and are not compared here.
Embroidery needle vs sewing needle, side by side
Put a size 7 embroidery needle next to a size 7 sharp and the shafts and points look alike. Only the top differs: the embroidery needle has a long slot of an eye, the sharp a small round one.
| Feature | Embroidery (crewel) needle | Sewing needle (sharp) |
|---|---|---|
| Eye | Long and oval | Small and round |
| Point | Sharp | Sharp |
| Diameter, size 7 | 0.69 mm | 0.69 mm |
| Length, size 7 | 38.5 mm | 37 mm |
| Size range | 1 to 12 | 1 to 12 (plus carpet sharps, 16 to 18) |
| Numbering | Bigger number is finer | Bigger number is finer |
| Made for | Surface embroidery with stranded floss | General hand sewing: seams, hems, buttons |
| Thread that fits the eye | 1 to 6 strands of floss, depending on size | Sewing thread, or 1 or 2 strands of floss |
The only real difference is the eye
John James, which makes both types, describes its embroidery needle as a sharp with a longer eye for stranded cotton, and otherwise alike in length, diameter and point. Its tables bear that out. Of the eleven sizes listed for both types, nine have the same diameter. At sizes 2 and 4 the embroidery needle is one wire step thicker. Lengths match at the fine end and differ by 1.5 mm or less at most other sizes.
The eye matters because embroidery floss is used several strands at a time. In a long eye the strands lie side by side and slide through together. In a round eye they bunch up, catch on the way in and rub on every stitch, which wears the floss at the fold.
Can I use regular needles for embroidery?
Yes, for 1 or 2 strands. A sharp has the same point and shaft as an embroidery needle of its size, so it pierces the fabric and leaves the same hole. For fine outline work with 1 or 2 strands, a size 9 or 10 sharp does what a size 9 or 10 embroidery needle does, as long as you can thread it.
It stops working at 3 strands and above. The strands either will not go through the round eye, or they go through squeezed and start to fray within a few stitches. Moving to a much thicker sharp gets a bigger eye, but the thicker shaft then makes a hole larger than the thread needs. How many strands a design calls for is in the strands of floss chart.
Note.Sign that the eye is too small: the floss looks fuzzy or thin just behind the needle after a few stitches. Change the needle, not the thread.
Choose an embroidery needle when
A pack of embroidery needles earns its place as soon as the thread is thicker than sewing thread or you thread the needle often. These are the cases where the long eye pays off.
- You stitch with 3 or more strands of floss. Three to six strands need the long eye, in sizes 7 down to 3.
- You use thread that does not divide and is thicker than sewing thread, such as pearl cotton.
- You re-thread often. Floss is cut to about 18 in (50 cm) at a time, so one design means threading the needle many times.
- You want one pack for every job. A mixed pack of sizes 3 to 9 covers 1 to 6 strands.
Choose a regular sharp when
The needles already in the sewing box are enough in a few cases. All of them involve thin thread, where the small round eye is no handicap.
- You are trying embroidery for the first time with 1 or 2 strands and already own sharps in size 9 or 10.
- You are sewing, not embroidering: seams, hems and buttons with ordinary sewing thread.
- You are finishing a piece with sewing thread, for example stitching a fabric or felt backing onto a hoop.
Can you use embroidery needles for regular sewing?
Yes. An embroidery needle is a sharp with a longer eye, so it goes through fabric the same way and leaves the same hole. Nothing is lost by sewing a hem or a button with one, and the long eye is easier to thread. For hand sewing, match the size as you would with sharps: a higher number for fine fabric, a lower number for heavy fabric.
The swap that does not work is a tapestry needle. Cross stitch needles are blunt. They are made to pass through the open holes of aida, not to pierce woven fabric. If your embroidery needle struggles to thread even with its long eye, a needle threader for multi-strand floss solves that without changing the needle.
How to tell which needle you have
Loose needles carry no markings, so sort them by the eye and the tip. Hold the needle up to the light, look at the shape of the eye, then check whether the tip is pointed or rounded.
- Long narrow slot, sharp point: an embroidery (crewel) needle. Find its size in the hand embroidery needle size chart.
- Small round eye, sharp point, medium length: a sharp, the regular sewing needle.
- Small round eye, sharp point, noticeably short: a between, the quilting needle. A size 7 between is 31.5 mm long, against 37 mm for a size 7 sharp.
- Large eye, blunt rounded tip: a tapestry needle for counted work. Sizes are in the cross stitch needle size chart.
Quick answers
Short answers on embroidery needles vs sewing needles. Both are hand needles, and the same size number means the same thickness at most sizes.
- Do you need a specific needle for embroidery? Not for 1 or 2 strands of floss, where a regular sharp works. For 3 or more strands you need the longer eye of an embroidery needle.
- Do I need embroidery needles? Yes, if you stitch with 3 to 6 strands or with pearl cotton. They also save time if you thread the needle often.
- Can you use embroidery needles for regular sewing? Yes. The point and shaft match a sharp of the same size, and the longer eye is easier to thread.
- What about embroidery needles vs sharps? 'Sharp' is the trade name for the regular sewing needle, so it is the same comparison: same point, shorter round eye.
What you need for this
- See price on AmazonAmazon
Clover Gold Eye Embroidery Needles, 16 Pack
- See price on AmazonAmazon
BEADNOVA stainless steel needle threaders, 20 pcs
From Best embroidery needle threaders for multi-strand floss
- See price on AmazonAmazon
PARKUVALLEY magnetic needle minders, set of 3